Say it out loud: I think, I thought. I be, I was. Now say I walk, I walked. One of these patterns is a tidy rule. The other looks like a pile of leftovers, and it is. English once had seven competing ways of forming a past tense. Six of them gradually faded. The leftovers are the irregular verbs, and what decides which ones survive turns out to be a clean piece of arithmetic.
In 2007 a team led by Erez Lieberman and Martin Nowak, publishing in Nature, followed 177 irregular verbs from Old English through Middle English into the language we speak now. Of those 177, 145 were still irregular in Middle English. Only 98 are irregular today. The rest slid over to the regular -ed ending. Help, laugh, reach, walk and work are among the verbs that made the switch.
The surprise was not that verbs regularize. It was how predictably they do it. The rate depends on how often a verb is used, and it follows a square-root rule: the rate is inversely proportional to the square root of the usage frequency. A verb used 100 times less often regularizes 10 times as fast.
Children learn a past tense by hearing it. A form you hear constantly, like went or was, gets reinforced every day, so nobody has a reason to replace it. A rare form is heard so seldom that each new generation may never meet it, and the regular rule steps in to fill the gap. Rare irregulars are forgotten; common ones are rehearsed.
The numbers in the study make the point. The half-life of be, the time for half of speakers' use of an irregular form to change over, comes out around 38,800 years. For think it is about 14,400 years. These verbs will effectively never become regular. At the other end, shrive has a half-life near 300 years and smite near 700.
Each green dot is a speaker still using the irregular past tense; grey dots have switched to -ed. The slider is frequency relative to think, with half-life scaling as the square root. The presets use the half-lives reported for those verbs, which set their relative frequencies: be is about 7 times as common as think by this rule, smite about 400 times rarer. These are what the model implies, not corpus counts. Drag to the far left and watch the dots drain.
The same maths lets the authors forecast. They projected that wed will likely be the next verb to regularize, with the quip that now may be your last chance to be a newly wed. Over the next 500 years they expect around 15 of today's 98 irregular verbs to regularize, though almost certainly none of the ten most common: be, have, do, go, say, can, will, see, take, get.
That is a striking idea: no committee decides that a word is retired. Millions of small, quiet choices, each weighted by how often the word is heard, add up to a curve you can write down. A language keeps its oldest, strangest forms exactly where people use them most, and loses them where they are least often said.
One caution: the half-life is a model of a population, not a prediction for any one speaker, and it rests on treating each verb as changing independently. It describes the trend across many verbs well; it cannot tell you the week a particular word will tip.