Music & Sound

Why a piano has 12 notes: the circle of fifths that never quite closes

30seconds
The 30-second version

Stack pure 3:2 fifths, the most consonant interval after the octave, and you'd expect to eventually land back on your starting note. You never do. After twelve fifths you overshoot by a sliver called the Pythagorean comma, about a quarter of a semitone.

The piano's twelve notes are a clever cheat: 12 happens to be the smallest number that splits the octave into steps with a nearly perfect fifth, off by just 2 cents. Stack the fifths yourself and see why.

Deep dive · 5 min

More in Music & Sound

View all →
Why a piano can never be perfectly in tune: twelve fifths overshoot seven octaves Climb twelve perfect fifths and you should land back on your starting note, seven octaves up. You don't: you overshoot by 23.46 cents, nearly a quarter of a… Music & Sound4 min read Why a flute and a clarinet sound different on the same note: harmonics and timbre Play the same note on a flute and a clarinet, at the same pitch and loudness, and you can still tell them apart at once. That difference is called timbre, and… Music & Sound4 min read Why sand on a vibrating plate draws pictures: Chladni figures Sprinkle sand on a thin metal plate, draw a violin bow along its edge, and the sand leaps into sharp, symmetrical lines. Change the pitch and the picture… Music & Sound4 min read Why a tone can climb forever without getting higher: the Shepard illusion Play a tone that climbs and climbs, forever, and never gets any higher. It sounds impossible, but it only takes a few sine waves and one volume curve. A… Music & Sound3 min read Why you hear bass from a speaker too small to make it: the missing fundamental Your phone speaker is far too small to produce a deep bass note, yet you still hear the bass. The trick is that pitch is not a frequency in the air. It is a… Music & Sound3 min read Why guitar frets get closer together as you go up the neck Guitar frets crowd together toward the body because of one fact about hearing: we hear pitch by ratio, not by difference. Each fret has to raise the note by… Music & Sound5 min read