Economics

Why rival ice-cream carts end up side by side: Hotelling's beach

Two ice-cream carts standing almost side by side in the middle of a beach, with the sand split into two colours by nearest cart
30seconds
The 30-second version

Put two ice-cream carts on a long beach and each one is tempted to creep toward the other, because standing next to a rival steals customers without losing any. Economist Harold Hotelling spotted this in 1929.

Drag the carts and watch them huddle in the middle. Each keeps half the customers, but everyone at the far ends of the beach now walks twice as far as they would if the carts stood at the quarter points.

Deep dive · 4 min
Deep dive · 4 min

More in Economics

View all →
Why a tax lands on whoever can't walk away: tax incidence and the wedge The law decides who hands over the money for a tax, but not who ends up poorer. Put a tax on a market and two prices appear: what the buyer pays and what the… Economics5 min read Why fair coin flips end with one person owning almost everything: the yard-sale model of wealth Give 60 people 100 coins each and let them trade by fair coin flips, with the stake a fixed share of the poorer person's wealth. Nobody has any skill or… Economics4 min read Why a healthy bank can still collapse: Diamond and Dybvig's bank run A bank keeps only a slice of your deposit as cash and lends the rest for years, so it quietly bets that almost nobody asks for their money at once. Diamond and… Economics4 min read Why a country that's worse at everything still gains from trade: Ricardo's comparative advantage How can a country that is worse at everything still gain from trade? Ricardo's 1817 England-and-Portugal example says the answer is not who is faster, but what… Economics4 min read Why two ice-cream vendors end up side by side: Hotelling's beach Two ice-cream vendors share a long beach, and every swimmer walks to the nearer cart. Where should each one park? Drag the carts and watch the dividing line… Economics4 min read Why a free shortcut can make everyone's commute longer: Braess's paradox Build a brand-new road and every commute gets longer. In a town of 4,000 drivers, two routes each take 65 minutes. Add a free shortcut and each driver… Economics5 min read